I vaguely remember participating in the Caldecott Medal reading challenge in first grade, and now I have proof thanks to the great basement cleanout in Ohio. This list also demonstrates my lifelong commitment to both lists and picture books, ha. However, it is incomplete.
So, I made a prettier one. With 34 more books listed (ack!). Feel free to download and print it out for your fridge if you are a checklist kind of reader—just click the little graphic to open it up!